How Will You Wager?

Dua Lipa exists. That doesn’t mean I trust her.

There is undeniable allure in risk. That rush in your stomach as you ski down the mountain, traversing between snow and the tree lines, between this life and the next. Hitting “send” on that risky text before flinging your phone to the other side of the room. Hesitantly accepting a mixed drink at the pregame concocted by the friend who has no intention of going home before 6 AM.

For founders, risk isn’t occasional. It is the job, and it decides whether they succeed or fail. Sam Goodwin, one of our guest speakers at Fides’ last Awards Night, gave the following advice to aspiring entrepreneurs in the audience: just start. That is the best way to begin. He said, “The cost of delay compounds faster than the cost of being wrong.”

Fortes fortuna juvat. Fortune favors the bold.

Entrepreneurs and Catholics are in the same business: betting on what they can’t fully prove.

📅 Upcoming Events

Gamblers Are Not Entirely Crazy

A friend’s great-grandfather gambled all his life. Three times he lost the family fortune, coffee plantation and all, and won it back. Shortly before he died, he bet once more and lost, to the dismay of his descendants. Maybe if he had lived a few years longer…

Why would anyone bet everything on an uncertain outcome? I’m not defending compulsive gambling. But risk means acting on a conviction without complete proof, and we all make decisions that way. A poker shark can’t see his opponent’s cards. He weighs the odds, reads faces, and acts—without certainty, but not without judgment.

An idea is safe as long as it stays on paper, or in the mind. That changes when applied to reality. Take Communism. It feels good to talk about dismantling the system! It does not feel so good to starve, or have your life reduced to another number, monitored by the State. Reality does not provide data in advance, nor does it promise a sure outcome. Human reason has its limits. 

`St. John Henry Newman coined the term “the illative sense”. It’s the mind’s ability to gather many small, converging reasons and reach a real conclusion, even when no single reason proves it. He laid it out in Grammar of Assent, part of his life’s work of showing that belief in God is not unreasonable.

St, John Henry Newman

We use the illative sense constantly. Entrepreneurs often know something is worth building before they can say why. As we saw last week, Mr. Moran doesn’t pick companies by the numbers alone. He reads people and trusts what he sees, without relying on research or the confirmation a spreadsheet provides.

In his interview with Jonathan Bi, Moran gives investors simple advice: circumscribe what you know. Draw a clear line around your real knowledge and act with confidence inside it. The opposite mistake is the “more I know, the better” fallacy: the belief that one more report or one more month of research will finally decide for you. It won’t. At some point the data stops, and you have to choose.

Catholics Make Bets Without Full Certainty Too

Speaking of having to choose, French mathematician Blaise Pascal offers prudential, rather than theoretical, reasons for believing in God’s existence, using decision theory. God is infinite, and we are finite—infinite chaos separates us, he says.

❝

At the far end of this infinite distance, a coin is being spun which will come down heads or tails. How will you wager?

Blaise Pascal, Pensées

Pascal frames it as a wager: bet on God and you stand to gain everything; bet against Him and you risk losing everything. And you can’t sit out. “You are embarked!” Pascal declares. Not choosing is a choice.

To the modern skeptic, faith is a crutch, something people turn to because they can’t stand the possibility that this is all there is. They can’t bear to stare into the void. Religion, as Marx put it, is the opium of the people.

The Church has always taught that reason is not the enemy of faith. They are complementary. St. Thomas Aquinas is arguably the greatest champion of reconciling the two. His Five Ways are arguments by which natural reason can arrive at the existence of God.

Reason is not the only witness. When we stand before a great painting or hear beautiful music, something in us aches. We become aware of a lack, and it evokes a longing for something beyond ourselves. That ache is the wound of beauty. We can’t prove where that longing points, but we know it points beyond what is perceivable by our senses alone. It awakens and reminds us of our innate desire for transcendence. 

But reason and beauty can only take you so far. Knowing God exists is different from having faith in Him. I know Dua Lipa exists. I would not blindly trust her to guide my life.

❝

Faith is the assurance of things hoped for, the conviction of things not seen.

St. Paul, Letter to the Hebrews

Notice St. Paul’s definition does not say "the certainty of things already proven." If it did, nobody would need it.

Faith is not oriented towards a conclusion in a demonstrative argument. It is trust in a Person. At the very heart of being a Catholic is an encounter with an event, a Person.

❝

And the Word became Flesh and dwelt among us.

John 1:14

Holiness is communion with God, and being His instrument in bringing about the salvation of the world.

Caravaggio, The Calling of Saint Matthew, 1599–1600. Oil on canvas. Contarelli Chapel, San Luigi dei Francesi, Rome.

What You Build Shows What You Believe

If faith and founding both demand action, then our actions reveal what we actually believe. A company is a creed made visible. What you build, and how you build it, says more about your convictions than anything you say.

So here is the challenge for Catholic founders. For too long, many of us have been content to preserve our inheritance: guarding the cathedrals, books, and traditions others built. That work matters. But we are also called to create things worth preserving.

The house always wins. Good thing it’s our Father’s.

Sortes mittuntur in sinum, sed a Domino temperantur.

“Lots are cast into the lap, but they are disposed of by the Lord.”

—Proverbs 16:33

In Christ,

Luca

Shred the slopes with Fides Entrepreneurship!

Until now, Fides retreats have been reserved for members. Starting this season, they are open to everyone.

Our first retreat in Cape Cod this summer showed us what these weekends can be: good conversation, faith, great food, and friendships that last well beyond the trip. We want more of you to experience that.

The 2026–27 retreats:

Stowe, Vermont: December 11–13, 2026 (ski weekend)

The Hamptons: Memorial Day weekend 2027

Members will continue to receive a discount on every retreat.

We hope to see you on the mountain.

Thank you to our sponsors!

My Catholic Library is a subscription book club for Catholics who want to read more and read well. Each month, members receive a carefully chosen book on faith delivered straight to their door, from beloved spiritual classics to treasured titles long out of print. No endless scrolling for your next read. No guessing which edition to buy. Just good books, chosen with care, waiting for you when you get home. It's a simple way to make room for good reading in a busy life, and over time, to build a shelf worth passing down.

Mater Rosae is a Catholic devotional jewelry brand founded on a simple but powerful idea: A Rosary in Your Hands, Always. Its Rosary Rings are designed to help the faithful carry the Rosary wherever they go, keeping it present, visible, and always within reach. Each ring incorporates the ten beads and cross of the Rosary into a piece that can become part of everyday life. The brand's mission is One Million Rosaries in One Million Hands, spreading devotion to the Rosary through its Rosary Rings and by supporting Rosary Makers in making and distributing missionary rosaries worldwide. 

The Padre Pio Foundation of America has spread the spirituality and teachings of Padre Pio since 1977, serving the sick and the poor through works of mercy. The Foundation helps sustain the places dearest to the saint, including the hospital he built, La Casa Sollievo della Sofferenza, and carries on his mission of hope and healing. Learn more about the Foundation here.

Verde Peak Partners is an Arizona firm that buys and operates enduring small businesses, helping owners step away while preserving the legacy and team they built. Led by a team of Arizona veterans, they put operations ahead of investing, and their companies include Shepherd’s Menswear, Watson’s Hat Shop and Rite-A-Way Garage Doors.

The Napa Institute forms Catholic leaders through liturgy, formation, and community, preparing them to carry faith and truth into public life, from Napa to Rome. We are grateful to partner with them as we head into their NAPA Nights event this November. Learn more about the Napa Institute here.

Shepherd's, our official suit sponsor this season, is Kansas City's leader in made-to-measure suits, dress shirts, and jackets. Their garments are made in Europe from the world's finest mills and cut with an eye for timeless design. As gratitude for their partnership, anyone who orders through our Fides link will receive a free shirt. Shop Shepherd's here.

Bom Dia Bubbles was founded by my good friend Antonio Motta, a past Fides guest speaker. This crisp Brut sparkling wine from southern Brazil is fresh, elegant, and easygoing, capturing the joy and warmth of Brazilian culture. A bottle is perfect for celebrating or simply for enjoying the moment. Learn more about Bom Dia Bubbles here.

Young Catholic Professionals Phoenix brings together Catholics in their 20s and 30s who want to live their faith fully in their working lives. Through executive speaker nights, panels and mentorship, they connect young professionals with seasoned Catholic leaders and with each other, under their call to work in witness for Christ.

Roots Run Deep has crafted expressive, terroir-driven wines in Napa Valley since 2005, working closely with local growers. They generously poured their Sauvignon Blanc and Pinot Noir for us, both vibrant, balanced, and true to the region. Learn more about Roots Run Deep here.

Elevate Events is an award-winning event production company in Yorktown Heights, New York, with more than 35 years of experience. They bring DJ and MC entertainment, lighting and visual effects, and luxury photo booths and lounge furniture to weddings, mitzvahs, sweet sixteens, and corporate events. Learn more about Elevate Events here.